1915–16 American Cup
The 1916 American Cup was the annual challenge cup held by the American Football Association. The 1916 edition included 37 teams. The title was won by Bethlehem with a 3-0 win over the Scottish Americans courtesy of a hat trick by Neil Clarke making Bethlehem the first team to win the American and National cups in the same season.
![]() | |
| Tournament details | |
|---|---|
| Country | United States |
| Dates | October 1915 – June 1916 |
| Teams | 37 |
| Final positions | |
| Champions | Bethlehem (2nd title) |
| Runners-up | Scottish American |
Preliminary round
The draw for the preliminary and first rounds was held October 2, 1915 at the Continental Hotel in Newark, NJ. The Preliminary round was to be played by October 17 and the First round by October 31.[1] The Celtic club of New Bedford withdrew.
New England District
| Springfield FC | w/o | Celtic |
|---|---|---|
| [2] |
| General Electric (MA) | 3–2 | Smithfield Avenue |
|---|---|---|
| Gillispie Taylor Law |
[3] | Smith Harrison |
New Jersey District
| Bunker Hill PC | 0–0 | West Hudson Juniors |
|---|---|---|
| [4] |
replay
| West Hudson Juniors | 2–0 | Bunker Hill PC |
|---|---|---|
| 5' Allen 30' McCallum |
[5] |
New York District
| Degnon Boys | 0–0 | IRT Strollers |
|---|---|---|
| [6] |
replay
| IRT Strollers | 2–1 | Degnon Boys |
|---|---|---|
| [7] |
Philadelphia District
| Wanderers | 4–1 | Rangers |
|---|---|---|
| Weldon (3) Graham (1) |
[8] | Lunn |
First round
The Chicopee Rovers forfeited to Fore River of Quincy, MA while New York Hibernian forfeited to General Electric of Schenectady, NY. The Greenville Sporting and Soccer club had to replay the Olympic club of Paterson after the game was protested. The IRT Strollers protested the replay against Brooklyn for an ineligible player and proceeded to play a third game. Yonkers protested their replay because Clan MacDonald did not have an enclosed field so no gate was taken and a third game was ordered.
New England District
| Chicopee Rovers | 2–2 | Fore River Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| Logan Lowe |
[9] | 8' Harrison Wood |
| Farr Alpaca | 1–1 | Bridgeport City |
|---|---|---|
| 48' Hall | [10] | 88' Austin |
| Pan–American | 2–0 | Springfield FC |
|---|---|---|
| 50', 87' Tom Adams | [11] |
| Fall River Rovers | 2–0 | General Electric (MA) |
|---|---|---|
| 31' Jack Dalton 43' Tommy Swords |
[12] |
replays
| Fore River Rovers | w/o | Chicopee Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| [13] |
| Bridgeport City | 2–0 | Farr Alpaca |
|---|---|---|
| Satterwaith Happinstall |
[14] |
New Jersey District
| Alley Boys | 1–3 | Scottish Americans |
|---|---|---|
| 3' Del Brierly | [15] | Hemsley (2) Gradwell |
| West Hudson | 1–1 | Jersey A.C. |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Ward | [16] | 87' Harry Neil |
| Haledon Thistles | 1–3 | Kearny Athletics |
|---|---|---|
| 17' White | [17] | 7' Meduskey Meduskey 55' J. Sherlock |
| Babcock & Wilcox | 2–1 | Greenville Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 35' Bert Holden 2H' Ted Finn |
[18] | 15' Jack Parkinson |
replay
| Jersey A.C. | 1–0 | West Hudson |
|---|---|---|
| 40' James Ford | [19] |
New York District
| Yonkers | 1–1 | Clan MacDonald |
|---|---|---|
| 55' Carver | [20] | 12' Elliot |
| Columbia Oval | 0–3 | Brooklyn Celtic |
|---|---|---|
| [21] | 10' O'Hare 30', 55' Ellis |
| Continentals | 3–0 | West Hudson Junior |
|---|---|---|
| H.Hayes Lonie (2) |
[21] |
| General Electric (NY) | w/o | Hibernian |
|---|---|---|
| [22] |
| Brooklyn | 2–2 | IRT Strollers |
|---|---|---|
| 15' Dickson 75' Vandeweghe |
[23] | 17' Young 35' Reilly |
replays
| Clan MacDonald | 1–0 | Yonkers |
|---|---|---|
| 70' Elliot | [24] |
| IRT Strollers | 0–3 | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| [25] | Spicer (2) Shanholt |
| IRT Strollers | 0–1 | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| [26] | 10'Hunziker |
| Clan MacDonald | 3–1 | Yonkers |
|---|---|---|
| 15' Madden 35' N. Agar 70' Harrower |
[27] | Ernie Garside (pk) |
Pennsylvania District
| Henry Disston | 4–1 | Wanderers |
|---|---|---|
| Burrows Ware Rodgers Kirkpatrick |
[28] | Wislon |
| Bethlehem | 6–0 | Hibernian |
|---|---|---|
| 23' McDonald 65' Fleming (pk) Dean Pepper Fleming |
[29] | 35' Irwin Jones (og) |
| Feltonville | 3–3 | Falls CFC |
|---|---|---|
| 2' H.Derbyshire 70' Phillips 86' Shaw |
[30] | 22' Foster (pk) 32' Foster (pk) Clegg |
replay
| Falls CFC | 5–2 | Feltonville |
|---|---|---|
| 25' Clegg 65' Mellors Clegg 68' Kendall Mellors |
[31] | 27' Tom Derbyshire 2H' Tom Derbyshire |
Second round
The draw for the second round was held November 6, 1915 at the Continental hotel in Newark, NJ. Matches were due to be played on or before November 28.[32] The Falls Cricket and Football Club forfeited to Pan–American of Fall River, MA.
| Fore River Rovers | 2–2 | Babcock & Wilcox |
|---|---|---|
| Daley 80' Harrison |
[33] | 30' Millar Finn |
| Continental | 1–3 | Brooklyn Celtic |
|---|---|---|
| 15' Van den Eynden | [34] | 10' Ellis 30' Crone 65' Ellis |
| Falls CFC | w/o | Pan–American |
|---|---|---|
| Kearny Athletics | 0–4 | Scottish American |
|---|---|---|
| [35] | 50' Tommy Gradwell 75' Johnny Hemsley Tom Stark 88' Alec Bell |
| Jersey A.C. | 1–1 | General Electric (NY) |
|---|---|---|
| Kempe | [36] | 88' Lewis |
| Bridgeport City | 3–1 | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| Griffin Waite Heppinstall |
[37] | 30' Crompton |
| Bethlehem Steel | 2–0 | Clan MacDonald |
|---|---|---|
| Pepper Brown |
[38] |
| Henry Disston | 0–1 | Fall River Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| [39] | 16' Tommy Swords |
replays
| Babcock & Wilcox | 3–0 | Fore River Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 1H' Harding 55' Aitken 75' Millar |
[40] |
| Jersey A.C. | 1–0 | General Electric (NY) |
|---|---|---|
| 25' Jack Neilson | [41] |
Third round
The draw for the third round was held December 4, 1915 at the Continental hotel in Newark, NJ.[42]
| Scottish American | 2–1 | Brooklyn Celtic |
|---|---|---|
| 20' Rabbit Hemsley 21' Archie Stark |
[43] | 83' Charlie Ellis |
| Bridgeport City | 2–1 | Babcock & Wilcox |
|---|---|---|
| Satterwaite | [44] | 17', 20' Robert Millar |
| Jersey A.C. | 0–5 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| [45] | 23', 46' Pepper Neil Clark Fleming MacDonald |
| Pan–American | 0–2 | Fall River Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| [46] | 37' Tommy Swords 82' Jack Dalton |
Semifinals
| Fall River Rovers | 1–3 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 36' Swords | [47] | 30' Brown 37' McKelvie 80' Brown |
| Babcock & Wilcox | 1–3 | Scottish American |
|---|---|---|
| 60' Aitken | [48] | 10', 17' Gradwell Hemsley |
Final

The American Cup final took place in Taylor Stadium at Lehigh University in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. The Scottish Americans, runners–up in the National Association Football League, were the defending champions of the American Cup and it was their fourth final appearance overall. Bethlehem Steel came into the final having played 32 games winning 28 with three ties and a single loss. They had scored 116 goals with 14 against. On May 6 they won the National Challenge Cup over Fall River. Their American Cup win was then followed up by an American League of Philadelphia title when they were declared joint champions along with Disston on June 15. Neil Clarke scored a hat trick for the Steelmen with a goal in the 15th minute followed by two more in the second half.
| Bethlehem Steel | 3–0 | Scottish American |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Clarke (3) | [49][50] |
Champions

See also
- 1916 National Challenge Cup
- 1915–16 National Association Foot Ball League season
- 1915–16 Southern New England Soccer League season
References
- ^ "Soccer Enemies Caught In Draw". (October 3, 1915). The Sunday Call, p.18 col.1
- ^ "No Opponent For Local Soccer Club". (October 15, 1915). Springfield Union, p.23 col.2
- ^ "General Electric Wins First Round National Cup". (November 1, 1915). Daily Evening Item, p.6 col.6
- ^ Doc (October 18, 1915). "Sport Notes". Paterson Evening News, p.6 col.3
- ^ "West Hudson Jrs Win Cup–Tie game". (October 25, 1915). Newark Evening News, p.22 col.2
- ^ "Opening Game For A.F.A. Cup". (October 18, 1915). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.2 col.5
- ^ "With The Soccer Elevens". (November 8, 1915). The Sun, p.10 col.8
- ^ "Wanderers Defeat The Rangers". (October 17, 1915). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.14 col.3
- ^ "Rovers Play Draw With Fore River". (October 24, 1915). Springfield Union, p.2 col.1
- ^ "Alpacas In A Tie". (October 31, 1915). Springfield Sunday Republican, p.6 col.3
- ^ "Pans Win From Springfields". (November 1, 1915). Evening Herald, p.6 col.6–7
- ^ "Rovers Turned Current On And Blanked The Electrics". (January 10, 1916). Fall River Daily Globe, p.6 col.6–7
- ^ "Some Great Soccer Games Being Played". (November 22, 1915). Boston Globe, p.7 col.3
- ^ "Cites Trounce Farr Alpacas In 1st Round". (November 8, 1915). Bridgeport Evening Post, p.15 col.1–2
- ^ "Scottish–Americans Down Alley Boys". (November 1, 1915). Newark Evening News, p.28 col.2
- ^ "Jerseys Hold West Hudsons To A Tie". (November 1, 1915). Newark Evening News, p.28 col.3
- ^ "Thistles Lose Cup–Tie Game". (November 1, 1915). The Morning Call, p.3 col.5
- ^ "Babs Take American Cup Contest". (November 1, 1915). Evening Review, p.3 col.3–4
- ^ "Jerseys Win Cup Tie Replay Game". (November 8, 1915). Jersey Journal, p.8 col.2
- ^ "Exciting Game Here For A.F.A. Cup". (November 1, 1915). Yonkers Herald, p.10 col.6–7
- ^ a b "Brooklyn Celtics Win Soccer Cup Tie". (November 1, 1915). New York Tribune, p.15 col.8
- ^ "Soccer Football Card Varied One". (December 16, 1915). Passaic Daily Herald, p.7 col.3
- ^ "Brooklyn Sockers Draw In Cup Ties". (November 22, 1915). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.2 col.3–4
- ^ "Local Clean Up On Soccer Fields". (November 8, 1915). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.3 col.4
- ^ "Spicer Stars For Brooklyn". (November 29, 1915). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.3 col.2
- ^ "Brooklyn Reaches Second Cup Round". (January 10, 1916). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.3 col.3
- ^ "Clan MacDonals Clinch It". (January 17, 1916). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.3 col.1–2
- ^ "Disston Squelch Wanderers' Hopes". (October 31, 1915). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.20 col.8
- ^ "Bethlehem Eliminates Hibernian". (November 2, 1915). Bethlehem Globe, p.7 col.1
- ^ "Feltonville Ties Falls". (October 31, 1915). Philadelphia Record, p.# col.5
- ^ "Falls Outplays Feltonville". (November 7, 1915). Philadelphia Press, p.3 col.7
- ^ "Jersey Teams Draw Home Games In Second Round". (November 7, 1915). The Sunday Call, p.18 col.2
- ^ "Plays Star Team To Tie". (November 29, 1915). Quincy Daily Ledger, p.5 col.3
- ^ "Brooklyn Celtics Beat Continentals". (November 29, 1915). The Sun, p.8 col.4
- ^ "Scots Gain Third Round". (November 29, 1915). Newark Evening News, p.6 col.5
- ^ "Jersey A.C. 11 In Another Draw". (December 27, 1915). Jersey Journal, p.7 col.7
- ^ "Brooklyns Go Down Before City Attack". (January 24, 1916). Bridgeport Evening Post, p.12 col.1
- ^ "Soccer Cup Competitions". Sporting Life. Vol. 66, no. 23. February 5, 1916. p. 23.
- ^ "Disstons Beaten In Cup Contest". (April 25, 1916). Bethlehem Globe, p.12 col.6
- ^ "Babs Trim Fore River". (December 27, 1915). Evening Review, p.3 col.6–7
- ^ "Jersey A.C. 11 Trim Electrics". (January 10, 1916). Jersey Journal, p.7 col.2
- ^ "Ford Acquitted By A Single Vote". (December 5, 1915). The Sunday Call, p.16 col.2
- ^ "Scots Eliminate The Celtics". (January 10, 1916). Newark Evening News, p.6 col.3–4
- ^ "B–W Eleven Trims Cities By One Goal". (April 3, 1916). Bridgeport Evening Post, p.12 col.6
- ^ "Jersey A.C. Out Of A.F.A. Contest". (May 1, 1916). Jersey Journal, p.4 col.4
- ^ "Rovers Again Hand Defeat To P.A's.". (May 15, 1916). Evening Herald, p.6 col.1–2
- ^ "It's All Over For The 1916 Rovers". (May 22, 1916). Evening Herald, p.6 col.1–2
- ^ "Scottish–Americans Defeat Babs' 3 To 1". (May 22, 1916). Evening Review, p.3 col.1–2
- ^ "Bethlehem Eleven Wins American Cup". (June 12, 1916). The Globe, p.3 col.1–2
- ^ "Local Soccer Champions Win Another Cup". (June 12, 1916). Bethlehem Times, p.# col.4–5
